The 17th American Songwriter show featured East Bay-based band, FIGHTING THE VILLAIN. The two band founders Cisco Estrada and Miguel Perez have been playing guitars together since high school. They officially founded Fighting the Villain in 2005. They had music with no words, not an unusual occurrence for a new band. When they found Caitlyn Mae Lunning about a year ago, she added the voice and the words and now the band has exploded onto the local scene. They added fellow Hayward High alumnus Danny Brown for drums, and are currently looking for a bass player. A friend who plays guitar, Tyler Holloway, picked up the bass a few weeks ago and sat in for Friday night’s TV gig.
These kids are a few years out of high school and already have a song featured on LIVE 105’s Radio Sound Check and they opened the Local Stage at Live 105’s BFD Concert at Shoreline earlier this month. They have developed their own sound and their musicianship is stellar. Their solid performances and riveting arrangements bear testimony to their hard work and craftsmanship.
They sang five of their original songs Friday night: “Empty Handshakes”, “The First Impression: The Final Showdown”, “Untitled”, “A Memory Lost in Time” and their LIVE 105 break-out hit “What’s Left?” All songs except “A Memory Lost in Time” were pretty hard driving rock with Caitlyn Mae’s clear fresh voice sailing over the top like the whistle above a train.
Overall the band’s song are packed with an immense amount of musical details, highly crafted and customized, bearing FTV’s unique sound. I suspect that Miguel Perez may be the guiding force behind the unusual imprint. His guitar parts define each song with Cisco providing a stylized counterpoint to Miguel.
In “Empty Handshakes”, Caitlyn Mae’s line “I just want to avoid this” is accompanied by Miguel’s guitar counterpoint harmonics. Each musician is added until the song just builds and builds. Right when you think the song is ready to explode, about 2/3rds of the way through, the bottom just drops out, leaving Miguel performing Bach-esque arpeggios with the bass punctuating. Miguel is joined by Cisco and then Caitlyn Mae’s vocals in imitating counterpoint. The three then do this amazing melody weave.
I had to ask the kids if they had any formal training and for the most part they are all self-taught. Well you really can’t teach instincts and sensitivity. There is an amazing amount of what appears to be classical counterpoint being utilized and with very satisfying results. I would have thought somebody in the band had classic harmony training the way the music is structured. Nope, it’s just their signature sound.
In the second song, “First Impression – The Final Showdown”, Miguel opens with a melodic ballad solo utilizing the rich lower strings. Then when the rest of the band joins in, Miguel jumps to a high melodic line that whales into a driving rhythm that sets up the vocalist. It is really a magnificent opening and the rest of the song sustains the melodic line as Caitlyn Mae and Cisco and Miguel do their contrapuntal dance together.
In the third song, “Untitled”, drummer Danny is just wildly driving the train the entire time. Danny is one of hardest working drummers we’ve seen. He really pushes himself and the drums to the limit. And this song is a case in point. The song is in this intense hurry the entire time. When Caitlyn Mae sings her “Woahs” in the middle of the song, the pressure is crazy. And then the whole bottom drops out and again Miguel drives it back up with more of his twisted German counterpoint. The song makes effective use of texture with its sudden twists and turns, dropping out dramatically to leave Caitlyn’s beautiful voice.
Possibly because Miguel and Cisco have played together for so long, they are able to meld their guitar parts almost as if each can read the other’s mind. Miguel often takes the lead, but Cisco is just as strong in the follow-on and blending and twisting. The tight motivic development and coherency of their arrangements is not accidental. Miguel and Cisco and Caitlyn Mae are often playing/singing the same melody but they twist around all over each other to create a wall of fascinating sound.
The fourth song “A Memory Lost in Time” feels like a stadium style song. For a slow ballad, there is incredibly detailed figuration in the drums with Danny making very creative use of ever changing fills and hits. Danny drops it down for the verse and immediately starts driving it right back up. About 3/4 way through the song it drops out again to Miguel’s solo on the melody, and then Danny comes in and drives it back up and the rest of the band comes in and underlays Miguel so that we’re experiencing what feels like a big coda with a huge melody that just washes over you. And finally Caitlyn Mae comes back in and sings incredible counterpoint to Miguel’s melody with a larger than life ending that is completely satisfying. This might be my favorite song. Hard to choose.
Their final song of the night “What’s Left?” is a great calling card song of what they can do. Like “Untitled” the song is in this incredible hurry and Danny just drives it relentlessly from start to finish. Caitlyn Mae’s vocals and Cisco and Miguel weave around like crazy, but also there is very effective use of guitar doubling slamming alongside the percussion to drive toward an inevitable climax, About a third of the way through Miguel takes another signature guitar solo and then Caitlyn Mae comes back in and the drums and the driving guitars propel the song forward and relentlessly to its very satisfying conclusion.
Fighting the Villian is a great young band, worth going out of your way to catch live. They have got their song-writing, arranging and musicianship down. They are working on a CD this summer. So be on the look-out for that as well.